for Centennial Redone6/26/2004 c1 
32PheobeColelovers
I had tears in my eyes. It was so good. It was so wrong how they killed off his character with everyone hating him and wanting him dead. If he had to go (which I wish he didn't) than I would like him to go out as a hero. Great Story
32PheobeColeloversI had tears in my eyes. It was so good. It was so wrong how they killed off his character with everyone hating him and wanting him dead. If he had to go (which I wish he didn't) than I would like him to go out as a hero. Great Story
9/5/2003 c1 Sum1
Cole is (or was) my fav character by far. Im with u, he shoulnt have dies at all, but at least in this version he died as a hero instead of the bad guy, ad pheobe liked him (yay!). Too bad u couldnt help write that episode!
Cole is (or was) my fav character by far. Im with u, he shoulnt have dies at all, but at least in this version he died as a hero instead of the bad guy, ad pheobe liked him (yay!). Too bad u couldnt help write that episode!
7/31/2003 c1 Real-Blonde-in-Florida
Very good! Much better resolution than anything the Charmed writers could have come up with. Thank you for giving Cole some dignity and purpose and for treating his death with compassion. I love the idea of him dying to save Paige - excellent. Please keep writing Phoebe and Cole stories though. We need them.
Very good! Much better resolution than anything the Charmed writers could have come up with. Thank you for giving Cole some dignity and purpose and for treating his death with compassion. I love the idea of him dying to save Paige - excellent. Please keep writing Phoebe and Cole stories though. We need them.
7/31/2003 c1 Tzarista
that was great and so sad.
you did a much better job at it than the writers that get payed to do this.
that was great and so sad.
you did a much better job at it than the writers that get payed to do this.
7/26/2003 c1 ema
wow, i wish your story was the one they're showing on our TV. it sad but more human. it make me feel better about everything that happen between Cole and Phoebe. after all, they've been together for more than 2 years. that means something, right? love the scenes between this couple.
Great story!
this is the first time I reviewed your story, though I always read your other stories, sorry.
keep writing!
wow, i wish your story was the one they're showing on our TV. it sad but more human. it make me feel better about everything that happen between Cole and Phoebe. after all, they've been together for more than 2 years. that means something, right? love the scenes between this couple.
Great story!
this is the first time I reviewed your story, though I always read your other stories, sorry.
keep writing!
7/26/2003 c1 Charmed Fanatic
This was great! What you wrote here...well, all I can say is that it would of been a much better and much more appropriate way for Cole to die. With a certain sense of dignity; instead of having him die like some common demon of the week, when we all know he was much more than that. I liked Cole...although I must admit (and please don't kill me all you Cole lovers) that his attempts to get Phoebe back were wearing a little thin up to this point and it felt like the right time for him to go. What more could he of done? Although I totally agree, his death was a huge thing and it didn't feel like it on the show. It felt like routine. Your story is a good example of a missed opportunity . It should of happened like this; or at least something like this. Good job! Also I thought all writing and dialogue here was done wonderfully! :-D
This was great! What you wrote here...well, all I can say is that it would of been a much better and much more appropriate way for Cole to die. With a certain sense of dignity; instead of having him die like some common demon of the week, when we all know he was much more than that. I liked Cole...although I must admit (and please don't kill me all you Cole lovers) that his attempts to get Phoebe back were wearing a little thin up to this point and it felt like the right time for him to go. What more could he of done? Although I totally agree, his death was a huge thing and it didn't feel like it on the show. It felt like routine. Your story is a good example of a missed opportunity . It should of happened like this; or at least something like this. Good job! Also I thought all writing and dialogue here was done wonderfully! :-D
7/26/2003 c1 Rachel Snape17
Excellent! This is a great idea on how Centennial Charmed should have ended- now, if only we could've gotten the stupid writers on the show to listen. I've often wondered why they killed Cole off like some demon-of-the-week when there were obviously so many other options to consider. This story does his memory justice, and that's the highest praise I can give you, lol. :)
Excellent! This is a great idea on how Centennial Charmed should have ended- now, if only we could've gotten the stupid writers on the show to listen. I've often wondered why they killed Cole off like some demon-of-the-week when there were obviously so many other options to consider. This story does his memory justice, and that's the highest praise I can give you, lol. :)
7/25/2003 c1 Robyn
I totally agree with you, that the best thing for Charmed would have been if Julian McMahon could have stayed in it. And also agree that the writers could have handled him leaving a lot better than they did! Long live Cole - keep writing
I totally agree with you, that the best thing for Charmed would have been if Julian McMahon could have stayed in it. And also agree that the writers could have handled him leaving a lot better than they did! Long live Cole - keep writing
7/25/2003 c1 mimi
Much better way for Cole - and for everyone else! Love your stories - and I stopped caring about the show, I don't know, probably just before "their" Centenial Charmed!
Much better way for Cole - and for everyone else! Love your stories - and I stopped caring about the show, I don't know, probably just before "their" Centenial Charmed!
