for Free12/17/2003 c1 an-angel36
aw dats soo sweet! i seems someting dat harry wud do in memory of his godfather. i agree wid u dat sirius aint dead! cant wait 4 da next book
aw dats soo sweet! i seems someting dat harry wud do in memory of his godfather. i agree wid u dat sirius aint dead! cant wait 4 da next book
7/15/2003 c1 Hedwig
Hey! Great job! It made me cry again. I'm not sure; either Sirius really is dead, but we'll see him again somehow, or he isn't really dead. 90% of me says he is, but I still have hope! I mean, JKR has got to have a reason for killing him off, and she didn't explain it too well, so that leaves Harry, along with all his readers, very confused and bursting with questions, right? You know how JKR said we would never see a living Lily and/or James, yet we've seen them in the 1st book (Mirror of Erised), and they actually talked in the 4th book! Add all the dreams Harry has had about them, and you can bet that JKR is going to do something similar with Sirius if he really is dead. Well, I'm probably writing a novel, so I'll stop here. Again, great job with the fic! It will be really interesting to see if Sirius really DOES get his name cleared in later books.
Hey! Great job! It made me cry again. I'm not sure; either Sirius really is dead, but we'll see him again somehow, or he isn't really dead. 90% of me says he is, but I still have hope! I mean, JKR has got to have a reason for killing him off, and she didn't explain it too well, so that leaves Harry, along with all his readers, very confused and bursting with questions, right? You know how JKR said we would never see a living Lily and/or James, yet we've seen them in the 1st book (Mirror of Erised), and they actually talked in the 4th book! Add all the dreams Harry has had about them, and you can bet that JKR is going to do something similar with Sirius if he really is dead. Well, I'm probably writing a novel, so I'll stop here. Again, great job with the fic! It will be really interesting to see if Sirius really DOES get his name cleared in later books.
7/11/2003 c1 duochang97
I liked that. I thought it was a better ending than Harry being all whiny and delinquent, although, I've never lost anyone that close to me, so I don't know how I would act in that kind of situation. As for if Sirius is dead, it's hard to tell, but I wouldn't be surprised if he wasn't, and the black curtain was the gateway to some sort of wormhole or something that's just very difficult to escape, but not impossible.
I liked that. I thought it was a better ending than Harry being all whiny and delinquent, although, I've never lost anyone that close to me, so I don't know how I would act in that kind of situation. As for if Sirius is dead, it's hard to tell, but I wouldn't be surprised if he wasn't, and the black curtain was the gateway to some sort of wormhole or something that's just very difficult to escape, but not impossible.
7/11/2003 c1 Liana
I really think u should change your summary cuz u will ruin the fifth book for many and if u don't that is completely slack
I really think u should change your summary cuz u will ruin the fifth book for many and if u don't that is completely slack
7/11/2003 c1 
4Missa07
I love it, I don't believe he is dead, he just can't be...i cried when i read it, it can't be true...but anyway...wonderful story...thank you
4Missa07I love it, I don't believe he is dead, he just can't be...i cried when i read it, it can't be true...but anyway...wonderful story...thank you
7/11/2003 c1 AshleySnape
I didn't read your story but you ruend the fifth book for me in your summery...
I didn't read your story but you ruend the fifth book for me in your summery...
7/11/2003 c1 Liz Lansdown
Hi,
I think this is the best fic that has dealt with Sirius death.
Thank you for writing it, it's beautiful.
Liz
Hi,
I think this is the best fic that has dealt with Sirius death.
Thank you for writing it, it's beautiful.
Liz
7/11/2003 c1 2Lily Skylo
Hello, :)
I completely agree... Sirius is NOT dead! he just went away for a while :) Great story, I am glad you wrote it, I think that he should be remembered by all as the great guy he was! Sirius Black is and forever will be the best character in HP! ;P
~Lily Skylo
Sirius Rox! ;P
2Lily SkyloHello, :)
I completely agree... Sirius is NOT dead! he just went away for a while :) Great story, I am glad you wrote it, I think that he should be remembered by all as the great guy he was! Sirius Black is and forever will be the best character in HP! ;P
~Lily Skylo
Sirius Rox! ;P
7/11/2003 c1 7Ai-Chan
Hmm... I agree with you about Sirius now that I think about it...
I agree you should also change your summary ^^*.
This story was really good D I enjoyed it. *needs the sixth book*
Just needed to tell you you did a good job ^^
7Ai-ChanHmm... I agree with you about Sirius now that I think about it...
I agree you should also change your summary ^^*.
This story was really good D I enjoyed it. *needs the sixth book*
Just needed to tell you you did a good job ^^
7/11/2003 c1 Chan Riddle
;) Like it. Sad though. :( The last line was real sad. :( But it was really written good. Nice job!
;) Like it. Sad though. :( The last line was real sad. :( But it was really written good. Nice job!
7/11/2003 c1 Kit Kat6
That got me thinking! I'm sure he is dead, well 99% sure but it is a bit fishy in places so I hope with all my heart there's a chance he is alive. It was a very good idea for a fic. It always annoyed me that Sirius "died" or whatever with his name still not cleared. The fic made me sad though *sniffs* especially the last line. Kit Kat ;-)
That got me thinking! I'm sure he is dead, well 99% sure but it is a bit fishy in places so I hope with all my heart there's a chance he is alive. It was a very good idea for a fic. It always annoyed me that Sirius "died" or whatever with his name still not cleared. The fic made me sad though *sniffs* especially the last line. Kit Kat ;-)
7/11/2003 c1 8CurveOfAWrist
Hey... I thought that was really cute. Really sweet. But still... YOU NINCOMPOOP! lol. sorry... please forgive me... BUT YOU TELL THE WORLD SIRIUS DIES AT THE END! YOU SPOIL IT IN THE SUMMARY! lol. Sorry... I just know that if I was going through this and hadn't read the fifth book, I'd have been really upset to find out that way. Perhaps you should just say 'over the death' and then warn that it is a fifth (and third I guess too) book spoiler. Not trying to flame or anything... I just know that I'd be upset if I hadn't read it...
^Crysala^
8CurveOfAWristHey... I thought that was really cute. Really sweet. But still... YOU NINCOMPOOP! lol. sorry... please forgive me... BUT YOU TELL THE WORLD SIRIUS DIES AT THE END! YOU SPOIL IT IN THE SUMMARY! lol. Sorry... I just know that if I was going through this and hadn't read the fifth book, I'd have been really upset to find out that way. Perhaps you should just say 'over the death' and then warn that it is a fifth (and third I guess too) book spoiler. Not trying to flame or anything... I just know that I'd be upset if I hadn't read it...
^Crysala^
